Instant Ice Packs vs Reusable Gel Ice Packs

Use a reusable gel ice pack if you're cooling an injury at home over a few days. Use an instant ice pack when you need something cold and there's no freezer nearby, for example at a match, on a walk or in the car. Many people keep a gel pack in the freezer and a couple of instant packs in a first aid kit or sports bag.

How instant ice packs work

An instant ice pack is a plastic pouch with a smaller bag of water inside it. The outer pouch also contains a chemical, usually ammonium nitrate, calcium ammonium nitrate or urea. When you squeeze the pack firmly, the inner bag breaks and the water dissolves the chemical. This reaction takes in heat, so the pack goes cold within a few seconds.

They're sold under a few different names, including instant cold packs, instant cool packs, instant ice bags and first aid instant cold packs. Steroplast, a UK first aid supplier, says a typical pack reaches close to 0°C and stays cold for about 10 to 15 minutes, a bit longer in cold weather. An unopened pack lasts around 18 to 24 months if it's kept somewhere cool and dry.

An instant cold pack can only be used once. After it has been squeezed, putting it in the freezer won't make it work again.

How reusable gel ice packs work

A gel ice pack doesn't rely on a chemical reaction. It's mostly water that has been thickened into a gel, with an ingredient such as propylene glycol added so it doesn't freeze solid. This keeps the pack flexible when it comes out of the freezer, so it can bend around a knee or ankle.

You freeze it before use and put it back in the freezer afterwards, as many times as you need. A home freezer runs at about minus 18°C, so a gel pack is much colder than an instant pack when you first take it out. You need to be more careful with it against the skin for that reason.

Instant and reusable ice packs compared

Instant ice pack Reusable gel ice pack
How it gets cold A chemical reaction when you squeeze it Chilled in the freezer or fridge
How cold Close to 0°C Around minus 18°C straight from the freezer
How long it stays cold About 10 to 15 minutes Depends on the pack and how well it's frozen, but usually longer than an instant pack
Ready to use Straight away, anywhere Once it has been frozen
Number of uses One Many, until it splits or wears out
On a knee Usually a flat pouch you have to hold in place Can be shaped and strapped on
Best for First aid kits, sports bags, the car, days out Icing at home, several times a day
After use Thrown away Wiped clean and refrozen

When to use an instant cold pack

Instant cold packs are useful anywhere you can't get to a freezer. If someone twists an ankle playing football or knocks a knee while out walking, you can have a cold pack on it within seconds instead of waiting until you get home.

They're light, they don't leak water as they warm up, and they can be stored for a long time without any upkeep. This is why they're often included in first aid kits, sports bags and car kits. If you keep some, check the expiry date every so often, and keep a thin cloth with them so you don't have to put the pack directly on skin.

Because they only stay cold for 10 to 15 minutes, instant packs are best for the first few minutes after an injury. They aren't practical for regular icing over several days.

When to use a reusable gel pack

For a sprain or strain, the NHS advises using an ice pack for up to 20 minutes every 2 to 3 hours during the first two to three days. Over a normal day, that could mean five to eight sessions, repeated for three days. Using instant packs, you'd go through 15 to 24 of them. A reusable gel pack can be used for every one of those sessions.

The same goes if a physio has suggested using cold after your exercises, or if your surgical team has recommended it after a knee operation. If you'll be icing regularly at home, a reusable ice pack is the more practical option.

A well-frozen gel pack usually stays cold for longer than an instant pack, which can start to warm up before a 20 minute session is over. Gel packs can be made in shapes that fit a particular joint, and many come with straps, which makes them easier to use on a knee.

The downside is that a gel pack has to refreeze between uses, which takes time. If you're icing every two or three hours, it helps to have two packs, so one can go back in the freezer while you use the other.

Using ice packs safely

The same safety advice applies to both types. Put a thin layer such as a tea towel or thin leggings between the pack and your skin. Keep each session to 20 minutes or less, and check your skin during that time. Pink skin is normal. If the skin looks white or grey, or feels hard or numb, take the pack off. Don't fall asleep with a pack on.

Gel packs need extra care because they're so much colder than instant packs when they come out of the freezer. Steroplast advises against using instant packs on people with poor circulation or diabetes, and it's sensible to apply the same caution to any cold pack. If you have either condition, or Raynaud's or reduced feeling in your legs, ask your GP or physio before using one.

Our guide to how long to leave an ice pack on goes into more detail on timings, skin checks and what to do if you get an ice burn.

With instant packs, there's also the chemical inside to think about. Don't cut, pierce or chew one, and store unused packs out of children's reach. According to Poison Control in the US, ammonium nitrate is the most harmful of the chemicals used if swallowed, and urea is the least harmful. If a pack splits, wash the contents off your skin with soap and water, and rinse any that gets in the eyes with clean water for 15 minutes. If someone swallows the contents, call NHS 111 for advice, or 999 if they become unwell.

The gel in reusable packs is much less of a concern, although swallowing a small amount can still upset the mouth or stomach. If a gel pack splits or leaks, throw it away rather than repairing it. Packs that are made for cold use only shouldn't be put in the microwave.

Disposal and care

Instant ice packs can't be reused. Steroplast says they can't be recycled and should be disposed of in line with local rules, so check the packaging and your council's guidance. Don't cut a used pack open to empty it.

To look after a reusable pack, wipe it with a damp cloth and a little mild soap after use, let it dry, then put it back in the freezer. Store it flat in a clean freezer bag, away from anything sharp. Replace it if the cover splits or the gel no longer stays soft when frozen.


CC

Christopher Chetham